Lucky falls over whiskers in love with Princess Belle's pet kitten, Rouge and wants to ask her out to the Whisker Haven Valentine's Day Ball.
The episode begins with the PJ Masks, Kwazii, Captain Barnacles, Sofia, Captain Jake, Izzy, Cubby, Skully, Sheriff Callie, Peck, and Toby helping the Whisker Haven Palace Pets decorate the ballroom for their annual Valentine's Day ball while the PJ Masks' shape shifting pets were sleeping or playing with Brie and Seashell. Just then, a heart-shaped disco ball begins to fall straight down towards Belle's pet kitten, Rouge!
Nearby, Lucky wakes up from Rouge's cries for help and he saves her just in the nick of time before the disco ball hit her. As he got up, Lucky stares straight into Rouge's eyes and saw how beautiful she was as Rouge thanks him for saving her life and gets up to help the other pets, but little did she know that her tail brushed under Lucky's chin and he was suddenly in some love spell while Kwazii helped fix the disco ball and levitate it back up on the ceiling.
Later, back home at Connor's house, Connor noticed that Lucky hasn't eaten his food yet and it was beginning to go bad.
- This episode features the song "In Your Eyes."