In order to save their friendship, Miles will have to divulge his secret about the Star Darlings to his best friend Haruna.
The episode begins on Planet Laikasa where Miles and Haruna are ready for some blastboarding. They couldn't wait to get started and Miles was glad that he was staying with his old friend for the long weekend. Suddenly, Miles' Star Zap beeps and he excuses himself as he opens his Star Zap and gets a call from Cassie.
When he answers the call, Cassie's face appears, only it looked anxious as Miles asks her what was wrong. Cassie asks Miles where he was and tells him that Tessa needs some help baking her treats for the Starling Academy Bake Sale. With a smack on his forehead, Miles says that he totally forgot and tells Cassie to not worry for that he was on his way as he ends the call and turns to Haruna to tell him that their blastboarding will have to wait another time.
Haruna was a little disappointed, but he did understand as Miles said goodbye to him and went off. As he left for Starland, Miles couldn't help but feel bad about not hanging out with Haruna more than hang out with the Star Darlings, especially when he had to help one of them bake the treats for some bake sale.
When Miles arrived (in his Starling form), Miles meets Tessa and Cassie at the Big Dipper Dormitory and went to Tessa and Adora's dorm room. Luckily, Adora was out so the trio can start baking.
As they put on their aprons, Miles, Cassie, and Tessa got to work on baking. They mixing the ingredients, made the dough then rolled it, cut out the cookies with a star shaped cookie cutter, and finally puts them in the oven.
After a few minutes, the cookies were ready to be taken out of the oven. The cookies came out great and they looked so good, that even Bitty wanted to take a bit out of them. However, Cassie stopped her as Miles and Tessa iced the cookies with special icing.
Miles helped Tessa wrap up the cookies in bags and was about to rush back to Laikasa when Cassie and Tessa asked him where he was going and also asked him if he wants to stay for the bake sale. Unfortunately, Miles couldn't stay because he promised Haruna that he would blastboard with him. Tessa and Cassie understood as Tessa gave Miles a bags of the cookies and he was off, waving goodbye to the two Star Darlings while riding his shooting star back to Laikasa.
When he arrived back, Miles finds Haruna already blastboarding on the ramp and runs over to join him. Haruna stops and rushes over to Miles and ask him where he's been after he left. Miles explains that he was baking cookies but didn't mention that he was making them with the Star Darlings, for that he was supposed to keep them a secret. Haruna frowned at the thought about Miles baking cookies with girls, but only for a second and laughs, then asks Miles if he was doing it for some Girl Scouts.
With his cheeks flushing with embarrassment, Miles replies that the cookies are not for the Girl Scouts, but just for a bake sale his friends' school was having and he apologizes to Haruna for not blastboarding with him earlier. So to make it up to him, Miles gives his friend the cookies and Haruna finds them delicious when he took a bite out of them.
After finishing the cookies, Haruna and Miles went back to their blastboarding.
The next morning, Miles was up for another day with Haruna as he went to his screen to call Haruna and ask him if he's ready for more blastboarding. Outside, Haruna was waiting for Miles when Miles came out with his blastboard and they high five each other. Just then, like yesterday, Miles' Star Zap beeps and Miles once again excuses himself to Haruna as he went back into his room to answer the call.
This time, Sage's face appears When Miles called her and asked her what's up. Sage tells him that she and the Star Darlings band are playing in a concert but they need his help because Libby is studying for her test, and they need a keytar player for their band so they could play at the concert which is today.
Sighing heavily, Miles replies that he's on his way as he closes his Star Zap and goes back outside to tell Haruna that he has another "meeting." Again, Haruna was disappointed but he understood anyway as Miles ran passed him and said goodbye before hiding behind a rock and unfolding his shooting star so he could ride it back to Starland.
Meanwhile, the Star Darlings band (minus Libby) were waiting for Miles when Miles arrived, all dressed in his Starling disguise. As they were all set, the Star Darlings and Miles began playing their new song to the crowd. After ending the song, the crowd cheered and the Star Darlings thanked everyone for coming to watch them sing their song. However, Miles wasn't in the mood for the crowd as he left and went back to Laikasa.
Back at the Stellosphere, Miles slumped on his bed, feeling exhausted. Then, his iDisney buzzed as he picked up just to find that Haruna had texted him. The message asked him where he had been and that he had missed blastboarding with him again. Miles could tell that the text message sounded annoyed, so he texted back to tell Haruna that his "meeting" ended late. After texting Haruna back, Miles put his arm over his eyes, sighing heavily again.
That morning after yesterday, Haruna and Miles and the robot pets were ready for a play date. But again, Miles' Star Zap buzzes and he was about to tell Haruna about his "meetings" when Haruna, with his eyes rolling and arms crossed, beat him to it. The boys laughed but only for a second as Haruna and his robot pet dog when back to their colony, leaving Miles and MERC behind.
After having to make excuses to Haruna to help the Star Darlings in Starling Academy too many times, the long weekend was over and everyone went back to school. Later, Miles was at his locker to grab his books when Haruna went up to him, only to not say hello to him, but he had a look of irritation on his face as he asked Miles what he was up with the meetings he was having and why he couldn't stay long to go blastboarding or do anything with him. Miles wished he could tell Haruna about the Star Darlings, but he knew that they must remain a secret, especially to Haruna.
In despair, Miles tried to reveal his biggest secret to Haruna, but failed to do so as the fear of losing his friend took over. Unfortunately, while coming up with explanations of why he couldn't stay on Laikasa with Haruna for long, Miles accidentally hurt Haruna's feelings, putting their friendship in great risk.
Haruna nods it off with understandment, and sadly walks off passed him to his first class, replying to Miles in an sad tone that he'll see him later.
With a wave of his hand, Miles softly replies that he'll see Haruna later, he guessed. That night, Miles was feeling conflicted about himself.
He asked MERC what he was gonna do while looking at his reflection in the hand mirror he held. Miles says on one hand, he doesn't want to keep lying to Haruna, but on the other hand, he wants to keep his cool and keep on keeping the Star Darlings and their world a secret.
All of this was making Miles stressed out and frustrated as he sat on his bed, resting his face on his palms. Feeling sorry for his owner, MERC wrapped his robotic neck around Miles to hug him and suggests that maybe a song will cheer him up and help him make his decision.
After taking MERC's suggestion, Miles hops off his bed, grabs his electric guitar, sits back on his bed, and starts playing and singing, My Starry Secret.
After finishing his song, Loretta appears at the entrance to Miles' room to check on Miles and asked if he was okay, because she heard him sing and play the guitar. In fact, that was the first time Loretta heard Miles sing and play the electric guitar.
When Miles saw his sister, his eyes filled with tears as he ran over to her and gave her a tight hug, his electric guitar still over his shoulder. Loretta hugged Miles back as he felt one of his tears land on her shoulder.
Two minutes later, Loretta, Miles, and MERC were in Loretta's room as Loretta encouraged her brother to tell her what's wrong. After taking a few deep breaths, Miles explains everything about Haruna, the Star Darlings, and having to make the excuses to Haruna to go to Starland. Then Miles tells Loretta that he thinks that he should tell Haruna the whole truth, and that it was time for him to know about the Star Darlings.
With a gasp, Loretta tells Miles that he can’t tell Haruna just because he wants to, but Miles protests that he should so Haruna wouldn’t ask him too many questions.
- The episode's title is a pun on the book and movie series, The Fault In Our Stars.
- The song, My Starry Secret, that Miles sings has the same tune as My Biggest Secret from Littlest Pet Shop, only it’s electric guitar themed and "biggest" is replaced with "starry."
- Haruna learns about the Star Darlings for the first time.
Miles (Narrating): The Secret In Our Stars.